BZU PAGES: Find Presentations, Reports, Student's Assignments and Daily Discussion; Bahauddin Zakariya University Multan

- Islam (http://bzupages.com/16-islam/)

- - کئی مذاہب والی محفل کو سلام کرنا (http://bzupages.com/f16/%98%C6-%E3%D0%C7%C0%C8-%E6%C7%E1-%E3%CD%DD%E1-%98%E6-%D3%E1%C7%E3-%98%D1%E4%C7-12251/)

کئی مذاہب والی محفل کو سلام کرنا

حضرت اسامہ سے روایت ہے کہ نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ و سلم ایک ایسی مجلس کے پاس سے گزرے جس میں مسلمان اور مشرک، بت پر ست اور یہود، سب ملے جلے بیٹھے ہوئے تھے پس نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ و سلم نے انہیں سلام کیا۔
(متفق علیہ)

Re: کئی مذاہب والی محفل کو سلام کرنا

then what those mushrik/jews replied in answering the salam?

I have heard that, saying salam to mushrik is not allowed...
2nd thing, here in this hadis , you are saying ..

Quote:

muslims, jews and mushrikمسلمان اور مشرک، بت پر ست اور یہود

In quran surah alanam, it is written, Muslims are not allowed to sit/make relations with mushrik,

جس مجلس میں ذکر نہ ہو وہ باعث حسرت ہو گی

3rd thing, can you tell the name of any sahabi who was in that majlis,

4th if it is true there were some sahaba sitting too in that majlis. then i am sure Muhammad SAW na un sahaba karam ko hei salam kia hoga, kafir mushrik logon ko nahi..

Re: کئی مذاہب والی محفل کو سلام کرنا

Quote:

Originally Posted by thecool (Post 25824)

then what those mushrik/jews replied in answering the salam?

I have heard that, saying salam to mushrik is not allowed...
2nd thing, here in this hadis , you are saying ..

In quran surah alanam, it is written, Muslims are not allowed to sit/make relations with mushrik,

جس مجلس میں ذکر نہ ہو وہ باعث حسرت ہو گی

3rd thing, can you tell the name of any sahabi who was in that majlis,

4th if it is true there were some sahaba sitting too in that majlis. then i am sure Muhammad SAW na un sahaba karam ko hei salam kia hoga, kafir mushrik logon ko nahi..

hoon, mera bhi yehi khiyal hay, ke yeh hades mann gharat hay, jaisa key yeh hadis yeh sabit ker rahi hay ke sahaba karam quran per amal nahi kerty thay:no:no..

Ya phir apnay molvie ko sacha sabit kernay ke liye, takay molvie sahab Christmas bhi mana sakain, Dewali bhi mana sakain,
jaisay Qadri sahab mana rahay hain..
Do not Celebrate Festival of Non Muslims, Speech by Sheikh Touseef ur Rahman

Re: کئی مذاہب والی محفل کو سلام کرنا

yups...mera bhi yehi khayal ha or jahan tk mujhay pata ha k salam sirf muslims ko kiya ja sakta ha.....non muslims ko nahi

i think quran k elawa sahi ahadees mein b isska saboot milta ha agar mein dhoondh saka tu zaroor share krnga....

or waise bhi jo hadees share ki gai ha iss mein bhi kahin yeh matlab nahi nikalta k non muslims ko salam kehna thk ha.....